If you’re a dropshipper using Shopify, chances are you rely on third-party fulfillment apps for order processing. These apps can save valuable time — but what happens when one of them glitches and your orders get marked incorrectly? Whether your order status is stuck on “Unfulfilled,” marked as “Fulfilled” too early, or duplicated altogether, this can wreak havoc on customer relations and backend organization.

TL;DR: A fulfillment app glitch can cause order status mismatches in Shopify. To recover, you need to identify affected orders, verify fulfillment details, and correct the statuses either manually or via bulk tools. Preventative steps like monitoring app logs and setting permissions smartly can avoid this headache in the future. This guide walks you through step-by-step recovery and essential preventive tactics every dropshipper should implement.

Understanding the Glitch and Its Consequences

Fulfillment apps are designed to streamline your logistics, but they sometimes experience communication errors with Shopify’s API. These glitches can occur from:

• Unstable internet connections during the fulfillment sync
• Bugs from app updates
• Duplicate tracking uploads
• Incorrect API responses or timeout issues

Whatever the reason, the results can affect your business in serious ways:

• Orders stuck in unfulfilled status, though tracking exists
• Orders marked ‘Fulfilled’ without actual shipping
• Duplicate order fulfillments or tracking
• Angry customers due to conflicting shipment notifications
• Inaccurate inventory or loss of control over returns/refunds

Step-by-Step: How to Fix Incorrect Order Status in Shopify

Step 1: Identify All Affected Orders

Begin by figuring out exactly which orders have been impacted. You can do this in a couple ways:

• From your Shopify Admin → Orders section: filter by “Unfulfilled” or “Partially Fulfilled.”
• Use query filters like date, tag, or app assignment if the glitch occurred during a specific period.
• Check orders from customer service complaints or from your Reports & Analytics.

It’s a good idea to tag affected orders with something like “glitch-review” for easier filtering during the recovery process.

Step 2: Verify Tracking Info and Shipping

For each affected order, verify if the item was actually shipped. Double-check:

• 3PL tracking systems (e.g., CJDropshipping, AliExpress dashboards)
• Tracking apps integrated into Shopify
• The customer’s support emails and communications

If tracking is present and valid, it’s likely the order was legitimately fulfilled but just not marked properly within Shopify.

Step 3: Restore Order Status Manually or in Bulk

You have two primary ways to correct order statuses in Shopify:

Option A: Manual Edit

1. Navigate to the order inside your Shopify admin.
2. Click Mark as Fulfilled only if tracking info is available.
3. Enter the tracking number, select the shipping carrier, and notify the customer (optional).

Option B: Bulk Fulfill via CSV or App

If you have dozens or hundreds of affected orders, you might want to handle it in bulk:

• Generate a list of affected orders via CSV
• Use apps like Matrixify or Easy Fulfillment to batch-upload correct fulfillment info
• Confirm upload accuracy and trigger email updates to customers if needed

*Caution:* Be extremely careful not to double-fulfill or send duplicate notifications by mistake.

Step 4: Communicate with Customers (If Necessary)

If your customers received incorrect or missing tracking emails, it’s wise to reach out personally or re-trigger Shopify notifications. Transparency in your message counts:

• Apologize for the delay or confusion
• Share the correct tracking number
• Offer a discount or bonus item for the inconvenience

This can turn a potentially bad experience into a loyalty-building moment.

Best Practices to Avoid Future Fulfillment Glitches

Nobody wants to go through this twice. Here are long-term strategies to prevent this issue from repeating:

1. Monitor Fulfillment App Activity

Most apps have an activity or log section where you can view fulfillment events. Periodically review them to spot errors early. Use Uptime monitoring tools if you rely heavily on automation.

2. Use Permission Controls

Limit permissions for fulfillment apps to avoid unintended updates from buggy services. Ensure they only have access to required actions and not admin-level controls unless absolutely necessary.

3. Activate Backup Notifications

Enable Shopify’s native fulfillment-sent emails even when your app handles shipping. This gives you a fallback if the fulfillment app quietly fails.

4. Keep Apps Updated and Audited

Always run apps on their latest version and audit your Shopify app usage every 2–3 months. Remove unused apps that might interfere with order processing or metadata.

5. Use Order Tags for Fulfillment Tracking

Automate your own checks by tagging orders during each phase of the shipping workflow. For example:

• awaiting-carrier
• fulfilled-manual
• pending-sync

This acts as a visual map of each order’s journey and helps you spot patterns if things go wrong.

When Should You Contact Shopify Support?

If the glitch caused financial inconsistencies, multiple customer complaints, or seems to stem from Shopify’s end — not just the app — it’s best to get support involved.

Reach out when:

• Shopify’s fulfillment logs show no communication from your app at all
• Refunds are blocked due to incorrect order statuses
• Duplicate fulfillments drain inventory improperly

When contacting support, include:

• A list of affected order numbers
• Logs/screenshots from your fulfillment app(s)
• Steps you’ve already tried

Conclusion: Glitches Happen — Prepared Stores Thrive

Fulfillment errors in Shopify due to app glitches can quickly disrupt your entire workflow — but they don’t have to ruin your operation. By systematically identifying, verifying, fixing, and then taking smart preventive steps, you can recover just like a pro.

Every glitch is a reminder of the importance of redundancy, monitoring, and process control in your eCommerce workflow. Don’t panic — plan.

---

Need more guides like this? Subscribe to our newsletter for weekly workflow tips, automation hacks, and Shopify process optimizations tailored for dropshippers and eCommerce entrepreneurs.